Top Ten 2024

Year after year I say it wasn’t a great year for movies, and the fact that I can’t find ten titles for this list reinforce that view for 2024. On the other hand, the industry’s policy of withholding prestige films until December makes it hard to catch up with everything, and there are two possible nominees, The Brutalist and The Seed and the Sacred Fig, that are still on our to-watch list.
1. Green Border. This documentary-like story of refugees trying to reach Europe made you feel and made you think like no other movie this year. The characters were vivid and compelling, their plight all too realistic, the plot unceasingly gripping.
2. A Complete Unknown. Great music, Timothee Chalamet’s Dylan, supporting work by Monica Barbara and Elle Fanning all combined to make this the most enjoyable film of the year.
3. The Apprentice. Sebastian Stan and Jeremy Strong’s Oscar-worthy performances unfortunately captured the Donald Trump we now know too well and a New York of ’70s we still remember.
4. Emilia Perez. An inventively audacious film that is gentle, sweet, violent and thought-provoking, all at once, with top performances by four leading ladies. And music.
5. The Bikeriders. A portrait of a time and place  and subset of people, redneck South, with the great Jodi Comer setting the tone.
6. Sing Sing. A feel-good play within a play by Colman Domingo and actual prisoners.
7. Evil Does Not Exist. A moody, ambiguous, elegiac look at Japanese culture and man’s relationship with nature by the auteur Hamaguchi.
8. A Real Pain. Jesse Eisenberg, not Kieran Culkin, is the standout in this very personal story.
9. Anora. The first half hour aside, Sean Baker’s film was funny, sad and original, amazingly acted and deftly directed. Why not in the top five? That first half hour.

A Complete Unknown – 8

The music alone makes this one of the most enjoyable films of this or any year. Hardly five minutes go by without another song, and it’s usually a great song we know and love, and it’s integral to the story. The actors do the vocals themselves, which makes it all more real, and they are good, especially Monica Barbaro, who looks great and hits the high, silver notes that made Joan Baez. A “complete unknown,” Bob Dylan can be played many ways, as Todd Haynes has shown, and Timothee Chalamet’s version is as good as any. We don’t learn much of anything about Dylan–he writes compulsively, he’s insensitive/rude to others, he lives in a bubble–but we feel his music. When Bob and Joan duetted on “It Ain’t Me Babe,” I broke down. And then there is “Like A Rolling Stone.” The movie wasn’t perfect: it was histrionic too often, notably in the Allen Lomax character. But he didn’t sing. That was Bob. And Joan and Johnny and Pete. And they were great.

Janet Planet – 5.5

As with her (much better) plays, Annie Baker’s film debut consists of people talking, and figuring themselves out. Unfortunately, all they talk about is their relationships, none of which are that interesting. This is sort of an Inside Out 2 but with sort of grownups.

Inside Out 2 – 6

Our 7-year-old granddaughter said she enjoyed it, although the jokes were coming faster than we could easily catch. I think I liked the first film better, but that may be because the early teenage years just aren’t fun for anyone.

Touch – 7

A lovely, gentle romance between a charming and gorgeous Icelandic man and a lovely and demure Japanese woman, told through flashbacks to 1969 London from a 2020 present. Besides whetting my appetite for Japanese cuisine, the film almost made me nostalgic for the days of Covid lockdown.

Last Summer – 7

If you’re going to have an affair, it’s probably better not to have it with your teenage stepson. That seemed to be the message of this very French film: lots of relatable characters, long takes, sex and bad decisions. It would have been easier to take if Theo, the 16-year-old bundle of animal magnetism, had been either more attractive or more pleasant, but he was a convincingly unhappy, irresponsible teen. The film belongs to Lea Drucker, who wore her emotions on her face a bit too plainly and never quite convinced us of her actions.

Taking Venice – 5

A disjointed melange of mostly still photos for a documentary that purported a big story–scandal at the Venice Biennale–that never showed up. What was Leo Castelli’s involvement? Who was Rauschenberg’s competition? Wasn’t he the “best painter” there? What did his later ventures–e.g., ROCI–have to do with anything? Why talking heads who arrived on the scene more than 40 years later, including a young art historian from Tokyo? It was fun to see Rauschenberg’s works, often over and over, but I missed discussion of their artistic merit, or the art of the other impressive American representatives. I felt continually short-changed.

Green Border – 8.5

A sober and sobering account of a Syrian refugee family’s attempt to reach Sweden via Belarus and Poland, two countries that kicked them around, and worse, like political footballs. Agnieszka Holland crafts her film, shot in black-and-white after an opening view of, presumably, the green border, in chapters told from the perspectives of 1. the family, 2. humanitarian activists, 3. one member of the border patrol, and 4. an attractive psychologist who responds, and is transformed, by 1, 2 and 3. Every character, and there are many, is compelling. The plight of the refugees is hard to watch but harder to turn away from. While the film’s message is a plea for humanity, you can’t but feel, as with last year’s Io Capitano, that you don’t want to be a refugee.

The Bikeriders – 8

A movie based on a book of photographs is a novel concept (if you pardon the anti-pun). Accordingly, it describes a place and time and a particular subset of people: bikeriders. Enough happens to keep the story moving, but without the dramatic tension of a plot-driven film. It’s watching people. And what people! Jodi Comer is Oscar-worthy as Kathy: she creates a character you believe in, and with her supple, subtle face nails every emotion, every reaction. Almost as magnetic is Tom Hardy as Johnny, the gang leader, who mumbles to make Marlon Brando proud. Austin Butler falls between Brad Pitt and James Dean but is much better than he was as Elvis. The supporting cast is stellar (who recognized Michael Shannon?) and the soundtrack, led by the Shangri-las, is an evocative joy. And every so often the camera frames a scene that you know must have been a Danny Lyon photo.

The Idea of You – 7

A love poem to Anne Hathaway, by Anne Hathaway, but what’s wrong with that? There’s a serious subtext of gender-based hypocrisy: society (i.e., social media) wouldn’t shame a 40-year-old man for an affair with a 24-year-old woman as they attack Hathaway’s character. But if the man has a 16-year-old daughter it gets a little trickier. I liked August Moon.