Top Films by Year
Top Films of 2020
Top Films of 2017
Top Films of 2015
The Reader 7
Here are some of my questions: If Hannah was not intellectually curious, why did she take so readily to Homer, Chekov and Mark Twain? If she was intellectually curious, why had she not taught herself to read, or asked someone to teach her, before she was 60? If she was a shy recluse, why did […]
The Wrestler 4.5
Yes, it was a virtuoso acting performance by Mickey Rourke, onscreen the whole movie, but it was like he was acting in a vacuum, or a paper bag. Evan Rachel Wood and the marvelous Marisa Tomei notwithstanding, there was no interaction with another person that engaged or convinced. No man approaching 50, who had abused […]
Rape of Europa 5
The point, the argument, and the cases were muddled in this recap of Nazi art looting. What the Nazis did was despicable, of course, but the case of a distant heir against a good-faith purchaser (or beneficiary) is not a case of good v. evil, and the film never recognized this. Whether Klimt’s portrait of […]
Milk 7.5
It’s hard to tell how much of the film’s power comes from its production and how much from the underlying historical events it portrays. Not in question, however, is the virtuosity of Sean Penn’s performance: the distance of Harvey Milk from the world of Mystic River adds to Penn’s credentials as the greatest actor of […]
Happy Go Lucky 7.5
A character study – no more, no less – of a high-energy, happy-go-lucky 30-year-old who is putting off adulthood for no bad reason. Her goofy intensity, or intense goofiness, can rub people the wrong way or be endearing: characters in the film showed both reactions and I shared them. At the end, however, I was convinced I […]